
3.5 stars
I have very mixed feelings about this book. On the one hand, Rainbow Rowell has again proven her skills as a great storyteller. She always has such great writing and I generally really enjoy her work. On the other hand, I feel like we were misled about what the story was actually about, and ended up with a character that felt like they weren’t always the adult they were supposed to be.
The blurb makes it feel like we’re getting a story about a woman who is finding herself after a divorce. I was really looking forward to reading about Cherry moving on, discovering her self-worth, and finding love again. Instead, we get 400 pages of Cherry constantly going on about how fat she is, how weight doesn’t define someone, and then bashing fat people (namely her sister) who take Ozempic to lose weight. You can’t say that a person’s weight doesn’t define them and then in the next breath say that people who take weight loss drugs are traitors. At one point, Cherry says that if her sister doesn’t like the way she looks, then she doesn’t like the way anybody overweight looks, which literally makes no sense. If someone is taking weight loss drugs, they have a reason, and it is their own reason. It could be a looks issue, but it could also be a health issue. But saying that they don’t like the way anyone looks because of it? Come on now. Towards the end of the book, Cherry and her sister Hope get in a fight about Hope losing weight. Cherry admits her and the other sisters started a group chat without Hope so they could talk about her weight loss and Hope says she didn’t tell them she was taking Mounjaro because she knew they would judge her. Cherry is so offended about Hope taking weight loss drugs. It just seems so silly to alienate your own sister about her own choice. They didn’t alienate Cherry when she admitted she was seeing and sleeping with someone while still being married, but they alienated Hope for taking Mounjaro. Unreal. Cherry can be mature for her age at times, and then very immature at others. It feels like she should have been aged a lot younger than she actually is. Cherry also claims to be comfortable and happy with her weight, but it is very clear she is not. Besides the fact that she brings it up constantly, she berates Stacia when she says she never thinks about Cherry’s weight and seems aghast that Stacia has her own body image issues because she’s “thin.” Thin women can have body image issues too. This isn’t solely an overweight woman thing. And again, it is okay for that to occur. It’s not okay for think women to put down fat women, but guess what? It’s also not okay for fat women to put down skinny women.
When Cherry was finally with Russ, it seemed like we might be getting the promised blurb. But that didn’t happen. Instead, we get this internal tug of war between Russ and Tom, which would have been fine if that’s what I was expecting. And then it was hard to root for either of them because they both turned out to be not great people. This is all well-written, though I don’t agree with Cherry’s choices at times. The biggest issue I have is the fact that almost every issue could have been solved if the characters would just talk to each other. Cherry’s marriage ended in shambles because her and Tom couldn’t communicate about anything. He left for California to work on the movie deal for Thursday and took trips for publicity events, and Cherry decided that it would be easier to just tell him things when he got home. She decided her career was more important than supporting him through this huge event in his life. I get that it’s not always easy to take off work, but he asked her to come with, and she said no without even trying. There was just so much that could have been solved if they had discussed these things like the married adults they are. I don’t agree with Tom cheating, but I can understand what led him to it. There was also no communication between Cherry and Russ, which again could have solved problems before they even came up. And of course, there’s the exclusion of Hope from the other sister’s conversations.
I get that this book was probably written messy and complicated because relationships can be messy and complicated, but it just seemed to be overly messy when it didn’t need to be. It sounds weird to say, but I think I prefer Rainbow Rowell’s YA books over her adult ones.








