
3.5 stars
I loved the premise of this book, the fact that it spans 4 generations and 3 countries and deals with some heavy topics. However, I felt very disconnected with the characters and story. For much of the book, I felt as if I was on the outside looking in, instead of being right in the middle of the story. The writing felt flat at times, and it was hard to connect with the characters. The descriptions of locations were lacking and there wasn’t a lot of explanation on the current events. While I have a pretty good knowledge of WWII and what went on, I don’t know as much about Cuba’s history beyond the basics. I think if people don’t have prior knowledge to some historical events, they are going to be lost in what is going on. The author assumes everyone knows exactly what happened during Fidel Castro’s takeover of Cuba and the different shifts in government and what brought about his revolution in the first place. It is also assumed that people understand about the trials of Nazis after the war and what it took to bring some of them to justice, as well as what brought about the splitting of Germany and the Berlin Wall. This was a major event in history, but it is barely glossed over in the book. It was also difficult picturing the locations where the story took place as there’s not a lot of description of the locations. At one point Nadine lives in New York, but you’d never know it as there is very little said about the city. And though parts of the story take place in multiple cities in Germany, very little is said about these places either. Having been to Germany it made it a little easier for me to picture the cities and places that were described, but other readers are going to be at a disadvantage.
While the characters are all faced with life changing events and difficult situations, it’s hard to connect with any of them or feel much towards their situations. It’s as if everything is being explained through a third party who’s missing a lot of the original story. There’s a huge emotional disconnect for most of the story, with the exceptions being the first few chapters with Ally and the last couple with Nadine. Though the story is also supposed to focus on 4 generations, Luna figures very little into the story, only briefly popping in to encourage Nadine to explore the past. She’s more of a vehicle to move the story to its conclusion than being an integral part of it. The parts of the story that include Luna are still more focused on Nadine and her quest for answers. And though there are plenty of supporting characters as well, you learn very little about them and forget them pretty easily, with one or two exceptions. They are more there to offer a few pieces of information or help move the story. If there’s a disconnect with the main characters, there’s absolutely no connecting at all with the supporting characters. The writing is very monotone, which makes it hard to care about what’s going on. The characters themselves give very little emotional response as well. It’s as if every single one of them was so disconnected from reality that they couldn’t be bothered to show any emotion at all. It’s a very odd feeling to be reading about these events and have all the characters act like they’re watching it from afar with no connection themselves to what’s happening.
The story does leave a lot of unanswered questions as well, though I can understand why some of then aren’t answered. With a story that involves WWII and other conflicts, there are simply many situations that are unknown and have no answers. Just be prepared for this to be the case, as there will be still be unanswered questions.
This really isn’t a bad book; it’s just weighed down by the writing.









