
3.5
We’re back on the roller coaster with this series. I thought I was going to be done after the last book, but I gave it another chance as this one was about Nancy, whose story I enjoyed in Every Heart a Doorway.
Previously, Nancy had returned to the Halls of the Dead, where people become living statues, posing for hours upon hours, not moving, barely breathing, basically being as close to a statue without actually being made of marble. When something starts killing the statues, Nancy returns to Eleanor’s home to recruit help. She is joined by familiar faces Kade and Sumi, and new character Talia. Together they return to the Halls to find out who or what is behind the murders and stop them for good.
I like Nancy, though being a statue sounds absolutely torturous. I’ve also enjoyed both Kade and Sumi, so having them back really helped the story. Talia isn’t given too much space to shine, which is okay since it isn’t really her story. She’s there to help complete a task and not much else. Since she never knew Nancy before, there isn’t any familiarity between them, like there is with her and Kade and Sumi. And while Talia is essential to the final conflict, she’s a lot more forgettable than the rest. However, my guess is we’ll be getting a book about her soon now that she’s been introduced.
I wasn’t really sure how to feel about the discovery of who the murderer is. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised, but unless there is going to be some major conflict or showdown with them eventually, I really like for it to be dropped. Not that there hasn’t been conflict and showdowns before, but it feels like it should be leading to something bigger. So if it isn’t, I’d rather it be stopped now rather than dragging it on forever. I also wasn’t a fan of the Lord of the Dead. When questioned about why he hadn’t done anything to help the statues, he states that he is the Lord of the world and has other matters to attend to. So helping people not get murdered isn’t important to you? If you’re a Lord over something, you generally have constituents, and should take care of them. He also states that Nancy was a perfect statue before, but since returning the first time, had been willful and obstinate, adjusting herself before the bell granted permission, and wondering if she was rebelling and needed banishing. When rebuked by the Lady, who states the statues did not have rules against love and questioning things, he states that Nancy is only a statue. I really wish he’d been eaten like the other statues, as he clearly had no care for them.
I think most followers of the series will enjoy this, as Nancy seems to be a favorite among readers. We’ll see what the next book offers.








